A no bullshit non-partisan comparison of political candidates
Aggregate score
Abbott 3.9Hinojosa 5.4 H +1.5
Scoring · Jurists

Originalism (Scalia/Gorsuch strand)
textualism & original public meaning, 1986–present

7
Margin
A +4

Originalism reads constitutional text by 1791-era public meaning; the major living case applications — Heller (Second Amendment), Bruen (carry rights), Dobbs (returning abortion to states), and Bostock (textualist surprise on LGBTQ employment) — track different parts of Abbott's and Hinojosa's records differently. Abbott aligns on Heller/Bruen (signing permitless carry HB 1927), Dobbs (SB 8), and a textualist 'state-power' reading of immigration enforcement (SB 4). Hinojosa runs against Heller/Bruen on guns and Dobbs on abortion but earns Bostock-flavored credit on the gay/trans panic defense bill (HB 73) and LGBTQ-protection votes. Originalism is methodologically formalist, so it's possible to score high while substantively disagreeing — but Abbott's record sits closer to Federalist Society methodological commitments. Abbott is the substantially closer originalism fit.

Sources

  1. Cassandra Pollock, 'Abbott signs HB 1927, Texas permitless-carry law,' Texas Tribune, June 16, 2021. (full list)
  2. Eleanor Klibanoff, 'Gov. Greg Abbott signs into law one of nation's strictest abortion bans,' Texas Tribune, May 19, 2021. (full list)
  3. CBS News, 'Texas immigration law SB 4, making illegal entry a state crime, signed by Greg Abbott,' Dec. 2023. (full list)
  4. 'Gina Hinojosa,' Wikipedia, accessed May 2026 — legislative record including HB 73 gay/trans panic defense ban. (full list)
  5. Originalism (Scalia/Gorsuch strand): textualism and original public meaning, 1986-present. (full list)