A no bullshit non-partisan comparison of political candidates
Aggregate score
Cornyn 5.1Paxton 2.7 C +2.4
Scoring · Institutions & organizations

Wall Street Journal Editorial Board

7
3
Margin
C +4

The WSJ ed board is pro-free-trade, pro-free-markets, pro-legal-immigration, hawkish on Russia/China, pragmatic on social issues, deeply institutionalist, and increasingly critical of MAGA excess while remaining center-right. The board has been explicit on this race: Cornyn is, in their framing, 'the senator the Senate Republican conference actually wants to keep,' and they have framed the Trump endorsement of Paxton as electorally damaging to the GOP. Cornyn fits the WSJ framework about as cleanly as any current Republican senator does: tax cuts, free trade, anti-broadest-tariffs, pro-Ukraine, pro-NATO, Gang-of-Eight legal-immigration engagement, institutional Republican posture, and clean process record. Paxton picks up some points on tax cuts, deregulation, energy, and crypto framework, but loses heavily on Trump tariffs, institutional corruption, Ukraine, and the chaos of his AG record.

Sources

  1. Sen. John Cornyn, official Senate website and 2026 re-election campaign issues page, accessed May 2026 (cornyn.senate.gov; johncornyn.com). (full list)
  2. Wall Street Journal editorial board, referenced by Bret Baier on Fox News 'Special Report,' May 20, 2026: Trump 'will deserve complete and total credit' if Paxton wins primary and loses to Talarico; broader WSJ ed-page treatment of Cornyn as 'the senator the Senate Republican conference actually wants to keep.' (full list)
  3. Cornyn vote on S. 744, Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act, June 27, 2013; RESULTS Act / Cornyn-Heller substitute amendment; 'border surge' Cornyn-Hoeven amendment incorporated into the bill. (full list)
  4. Cornyn votes on USMCA (January 2020); Senate Finance Committee record on free-trade agreements; Cornyn statements on Trump-era tariffs (2018-2026) including measured opposition to broad agricultural tariffs harming Texas exporters. (full list)
  5. Brit Hume on Fox News 'Special Report,' May 20, 2026, citing WSJ editorial on electoral risk of Trump endorsing Paxton over Cornyn. (full list)